Evidence record
CDU comparison sources and method
The site shows reviewed statements from vendor pages. Source dates and limits are collected here.
Reviewed vendor pages
- CoolIT CHx 2000 — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “Cooling Capacity 2000 kW” Vendor states 2000 kW cooling capacity for CHx 2000; cross-check separately stated 5°C ATD and product sheet before comparison.
- Rack Basis: “12 x GB300 NVL72 racks per CDU” Vendor-stated model-specific rack basis. Keep exact GB300 NVL72 configuration; do not generalize to all racks.
- Rating Conditions: “2000 kW cooling capacity at 5°C ATD” Vendor-stated capacity/approach-temperature pair; further facility-side conditions and test protocol not stated in this excerpt.
- Eaton ROL / RAL / RAA CDUs — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “ROL4000 2,000 kW @ 3°C ATD (500 GPM); ROL2300 1,150 kW @ 4°C / 2,300 kW @ 8°C ATD (400 GPM @ 55 psi); ROL1100 550 kW @ 4°C / 1,100 kW @ 8°C ATD (125 GPM @ 30 psi); RAL110 (4U L2L) 50 kW @ 6°C / 110 kW @ 12°C ATD (24 GPM @ 10 psi); RAA32 (10U L2A) 16 kW @ 12°C / 32 kW @ 24°C ATD (16 GPM @ 12 psi)” Eaton catalog integrates Boyd Thermal by Eaton; each model pairs a rated kW with its exact ATD and flow/pressure basis.
- Rating Conditions: “ROL4000: 2,000 kW @ 3°C ATD (500 GPM); ROL2300: 1,150 kW @ 4°C vs 2,300 kW @ 8°C ATD (400 GPM @ 55 psi); ROL1100: 550 kW @ 4°C vs 1,100 kW @ 8°C ATD (125 GPM @ 30 psi); RAL110: 50 kW @ 6°C vs 110 kW @ 12°C ATD (24 GPM @ 10 psi); RAA32: 16 kW @ 12°C vs 32 kW @ 24°C ATD (16 GPM @ 12 psi)” Same ROL2300 unit doubles rated kW from 4°C to 8°C ATD (400 GPM @ 55 psi); verify facility water temp and pressure drop.
- Redundancy Controls: “Seal-less N+1 pumps, automatic leak shutoff, 3X pressure test; 0.2 µm side-stream filtration & 500 GPM on ROL4000-48U65 only” Vendor catalog claims; 0.2-micron side-stream filtration and 500 GPM apply specifically to ROL4000-48U65.
- JetCool SmartSense CDU — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “Up to 300 kW per rack (in-rack L2L); modular row scaling 600 kW–1.8 MW (2–6 CDUs)” In-rack L2L requires 42-inch+ (1070 mm) deep 19-inch or ORV3 rack; ATD/inlet temp conditions in datasheet require confirmation.
- Silent-Aire Configurable CDU (SACDU) — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “SACDU 1050 (1,050 kW) and SACDU 2300 (2,300 kW) L2L CDUs” Document dated September 30, 2026; shipping scheduled March 15, 2027.
- Rating Conditions: “4°C (7.2°F) ATD at 1.5 LPM/kW; water primary / PG25 secondary; N+1 pumps on 1 MW unit only” N+1 redundant pump option is available on the 1 MW (1050 kW) unit only; confirm delivery timeline (Mar 2027).
- Motivair In-Rack CDU — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “cooling capacity of up to 105kW with IT cooling systems” Vendor states up to 105 kW for this in-rack CDU with IT cooling systems; conditions and exact test basis not stated in this sentence.
- Price Availability: “Request a Quote” Page exposes a request-a-quote route; no numeric public price was observed. This does not prove pricing is never published.
- Redundancy Controls: “Designed with redundant circulating pumps and advanced resiliency features” Vendor-stated design feature; no independent reliability validation.
- Vertiv CoolChip CDU Family — vendor claims read 2026-11-13
- Model Capacity: “70 kW (L2A In-Row); 121 kW (L2L In-Rack); 600–2,300 kW (L2L In-Row)” Nominal model capacities across L2A and L2L units; compare only at each model's stated ATD.
- Rating Conditions: “4°C ATD for L2L models (121–2300 kW); 11°C ATD for L2A model (70 kW)” Vendor table states ATD and L2A/L2L mode; facility supply water temperatures and pressure drop curves require datasheet/sales quote.
- Redundancy Controls: “Redundant variable-speed pumps, 50/25 µm filtration, built-in leak detection” Vendor family specification; confirm model-specific pump redundancy and spare parts.
Shared limits and how to read the claims
Vendor pages establish what those vendors state. They do not establish measured performance. The selected evidence does not provide a matched independent test, a public numeric price, or evidence of stability across dates.
Claims are bound to exact candidate and source snapshot hashes in the project’s internal dependency record. If a source or reviewed fact changes, every dependent page is flagged for review before publication.
Feedback
Feedback analysis used 21 selected records (2 posts and 19 comments) after documented exclusions. 18 matched one or more candidate concerns; 0 had matching recorded vendor evidence and 0 was fully answered.
History
These captures establish first observations dated 2026-11-13 (plus Johnson Controls document revision dated 2026-09-30). No across-date validation exists in this draft.
Back to the comparisonScope and disclosures
LiquidStack and Rittal add two covered seller groups in the new source register below. Earlier six-seller counts refer to the original CSV snapshot.
Sources for the added decision fields
Read dates and saved passages are below. Download these fields (CSV).
LiquidStack · Capacity and ATD
LiquidStack CDU 2.X: up to 2.5 MW at 4°C ATD.
End-of-row or rack-adjacent use. A headline rating is not a site load guarantee; obtain the full operating curve.
liquidstack-cdu2x · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.464766+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L43; exact character span 1945:1979 in retained returned representation
Snapshot c37aacb443c9a8dbe78a696dd4b11f9eabcad9115d6f8c6d310f5bd14e9ff12e
Claim fa0b58ef0b7cda374e5b548b0ca964a6f8808b3be25e594b60a75aa18c778830
LiquidStack · Facility inlet
The CDU 2.X page supports facility water inlet temperatures up to 45°C.
The page does not establish that maximum flow, capacity and inlet temperature occur together.
liquidstack-cdu2x · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.464766+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L82; exact character span 4017:4064 in retained returned representation
Snapshot c37aacb443c9a8dbe78a696dd4b11f9eabcad9115d6f8c6d310f5bd14e9ff12e
Claim ecbd51cf343e7fa27686810f7d3155f13959c75d4bc54018c2f46c1d66946396
LiquidStack · Hydraulic duty point
The sheet lists 3.5 bar / 50 psi available head at 3,750 lpm / 990 gpm.
Use the stated pair, not an isolated maximum flow; have the supplier confirm coolant and pressure-drop conditions.
liquidstack-datasheet · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.448369+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L48; exact character span 2862:2916 in retained returned representation
Snapshot de3b983b7f7f5cbe09e50da9b9d31f63b3476c0d021412077327c35cdad09a00
Claim ca7e3fe63cf276573c452ad6d75424d3371525b8b5d9d3ea77915ef606693841
LiquidStack · Pump modes
Single-pump mode provides internal N+1; dual-pump mode uses unit-to-unit redundancy.
Ask which operating mode your quote uses and what capacity remains after a pump fails.
liquidstack-datasheet · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.448369+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L47; exact character span 2761:2852 in retained returned representation
Snapshot de3b983b7f7f5cbe09e50da9b9d31f63b3476c0d021412077327c35cdad09a00
Claim a1962b58920de39b1ba4e062b4e4d16fb6c8944f1c2a83687994169a612dfb58
LiquidStack · Power and controls
Control options include differential pressure, flow or pump speed; power options include dual A/B feeds with or without ATS.
These are configuration choices, not features proven to be included in every quoted unit.
liquidstack-datasheet · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.448369+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L57; exact character span 3388:3443 in retained returned representation
Snapshot de3b983b7f7f5cbe09e50da9b9d31f63b3476c0d021412077327c35cdad09a00
Claim e69496ae08a5ec84fd9085c938fe50c2298e1db85fb20ba03a0abe5e8638be1d
Rittal · Liquid-to-liquid models
Rittal's US page lists a 150 kW in-rack CDU and 1 MW in-row CDU.
The same page's 70 kW rear-door liquid-to-air system is a different architecture. ATD for the L2L capacities is not stated there.
rittal-inrow · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.452543+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L26; exact character span 2136:2155 in retained returned representation
Snapshot 1dbee8db9d82e9c93f1a28f45c9054dac06701a8bcc3eb8c20f6b8b23ed42644
Claim f7e54483a62442873baa3f8d72b887cb2a054a202f1ae26f863ce56f8b32db38
Rittal · Service access
Rittal says in-row sensors, controller and pumps can be replaced while the system runs.
A vendor design claim, not a tested uptime result or a site-specific maintenance procedure.
rittal-inrow · Read 2026-11-14T03:51:58.452543+00:00 · Vendor documentation
Saved passage and hashes
L42; exact character span 4028:4129 in retained returned representation
Snapshot 1dbee8db9d82e9c93f1a28f45c9054dac06701a8bcc3eb8c20f6b8b23ed42644
Claim 092314a4b56abfd39123abb8d7b4d5684dd479d32fcd838f9f60c8883ec68586