U.S. employers · 50–499 eligible employees
What should an employee benefits provider quote include?
Ask each PEO, broker, or carrier for the same written breakdown so administrative fees, premiums, workers’ comp, and stop-loss costs can be compared side by side.
Quote request checklist
Employer size and locations
Confirm eligibility for your headcount and states: Cigna reports Fully Insured / Plus: 51+ required eligible employees; Level Funding & ASO Plus: 25–999 required eligible employees; standard ASO: 200+ required eligible employees (footnote: 50+ / 25+ full-time employees in most states; excludes New Mexico). (source); ADP TotalSource reports 5 to 1,000+ employees across all 50 US states (source).
Admin fee vs. pass-through costs
Separate fixed PEPM service fees from direct premiums, payroll taxes, and workers’ comp: Justworks lists PEO Basic $79/emp/mo; PEO Plus $124/emp/mo (no base fee); Payroll $8/emp/mo + $50/mo base — insurance premiums, workers’ comp & add-ons separate (source); Deel PEO lists Starting at $125/emp/month (no separate platform/payroll/benefits admin fee); insurance premiums & WC separate; promo 3-mo credit requires 2-yr term (July 15–Dec 31, 2026) (source); Insperity describes Fixed-dollar PEPM service fee (by headcount; flat on raises/bonuses) + separate direct benefit/tax/WC allocations (source); TriNet describes Tailored PEPM service fee + separate charges for benefits, workers’ comp, payroll taxes, and add-ons (source); ADP TotalSource states Custom quote (WC included in service fee; benefits billed per plan/elections) (source).
Funding model and claims risk
Identify whether the quote is PEO co-employment sponsorship (Co-employment under PEO tax ID; PEO may sponsor medical/dental/vision & 401(k) (CPEO & ESAC) (source)) or carrier medical funding: Cigna compares ASO: employer funds claims directly + admin/stop-loss fees (100% real-time surplus); Level Funding: fixed monthly + 50%/67% renewal surplus (source); UnitedHealthcare compares Fully Insured (fixed premium, carrier risk) vs Level Funded (fixed + potential surplus share) vs Self-Funded ASO (employer pays claims + stop-loss) (source).
ACA & COBRA responsibilities
Get in writing who prepares, files, and furnishes Forms 1094-C / 1095-C and administers COBRA. Statutory ALE duties: Same; statutory guidance applies to applicable large employer (ALE) members. (source).
Renewal terms and exit portability
Check minimum contract terms, early-termination repayment clauses (e.g., Deel 2-year promo Order Form), and HR/payroll portability (PEO co-employment on Rippling HCM (portable off-PEO without migrating platform) (source)).
Reviewed benchmark & statutory baseline
Context for every quote
KFF’s 2026 national survey reports average annual employer-sponsored premiums of $9,804 for single coverage and $28,303 for family coverage. These are not a provider quote or an exact 50–499 FTE estimate.
Source page · Check recordIRS guidance says applicable large employer members file Forms 1095-C and 1094-C annually and furnish a statement to each full-time employee. It does not establish a provider’s contract duties.
Source page · Check recordTailored PEPM service fee + separate charges for benefits, workers’ comp, payroll taxes, and add-ons
Source page · Check recordPEO Basic $79/emp/mo; PEO Plus $124/emp/mo (no base fee); Payroll $8/emp/mo + $50/mo base — insurance premiums, workers’ comp & add-ons separate
Source page · Check recordCheck the renewal rules before comparing the monthly fee
A plan you can start today may have participation rules to meet again at renewal.
Justworks · monthly review
Justworks reviews carrier eligibility monthly. Falling below the minimums can prevent renewal in the fall.
This is Justworks PEO guidance, not a universal rule for other PEOs or carriers. Source & date
Justworks · master-policy medical
For its listed PEO master-policy medical options, Justworks requires two enrollees from different households and 40% participation.
Waivers do not reduce that denominator. At least one W-2 employee is required; the company cannot consist only of unpaid owners. Source & date
Justworks limits COBRA enrollees to 10% of enrolled employees for these master-policy medical options.
Open-market plans have separate state/carrier rules. The limit does not decide any person’s continuation rights. Source & date
Broker or consultant pay
DOL guidance covers group-health brokers and consultants expecting at least $1,000 in direct or indirect compensation.
For ERISA-covered plans, the required disclosure generally comes before entering the arrangement. Ask for commissions and other indirect pay, not just an admin fee. Source & date