U.S. employers · 50–499 eligible employees
PEO vs. Level Funded vs. ASO: what changes?
Separate two distinct decisions often labeled “ASO”: HR/payroll administration under your own EIN vs. PEO co-employment, and carrier health-plan funding (Fully Insured, Level Funded, or Self-Funded ASO).
Scope 1 · HR & payroll administration vs. Scope 2 · Health-plan claims funding
Comparable model slots
PEO Co-Employment
HR, payroll & benefits sponsorship
ArrangementCo-employment; payroll generally runs under PEO’s EIN/tax IDThe PEO may sponsor pooled group health plans and manage workers’ comp. TriNet claim · Paychex claim
Who funds claimsPEO-sponsored or pooled carrier plans (or BYO plans on select PEOs)Admin PEPM fees sit separate from medical premiums and workers’ comp in Justworks, Deel, TriNet, and Insperity; ADP TotalSource includes WC in its service fee. Justworks · ADP
Material conditionsCPEO/ESAC accreditation, exit portability, and state/census underwritingTriNet notes HR ASO runs under the client’s own tax ID without PEO benefit sponsorship. Deel requires US legal entity; Rippling advertises leaving PEO without changing HCM. Rippling claim
Carrier Level Funded
Hybrid fixed-monthly medical funding
ArrangementEmployer-sponsored group health plan under employer’s own EINCarrier or TPA administers claims with integrated stop-loss protection. Cigna claim · UHC claim
Who funds claimsFixed monthly payment + potential year-end surplus shareUHC reports low financial risk with potential surplus share if claims run lower than anticipated; Cigna lists 50%/67% renewal surplus share on Level Funding. Cigna · UHC
Material conditions25–999 required eligible employees (Cigna) & state surplus lawsSurplus share applies only where allowed by state law (UHC); Cigna group medical excludes New Mexico. Cigna size rules
Carrier Self-Funded (ASO)
Direct employer claims funding
ArrangementEmployer sponsors plan under its own EIN; carrier acts as TPA (ASO)Distinct from HR ASO: here ASO refers specifically to medical claims administration. Cigna claim · UHC claim
Who funds claimsEmployer pays actual claims + admin & stop-loss fees (higher risk)Cigna ASO Plus lists 100% real-time surplus with integrated stop-loss; standard ASO offers optional stop-loss. UHC notes cash-flow reserves are needed. Cigna · UHC
Material conditions25–999 (Cigna ASO Plus) or 200+ required eligible employees (standard ASO)Cigna Fully Insured requires 51+ required eligible employees (footnote: 50+/25+ full-time employees in most states). Cigna thresholds
Attributed provider disclosures
Vendor claims only; confirm exact contract and stop-loss terms against written quotes.
TriNet (HR PEO vs HR ASO) · Vendor claim
Co-employment under PEO tax ID; PEO may sponsor medical/dental/vision & 401(k) (CPEO & ESAC)
Source page ↗ ·
Check record
Paychex PEO (EIN & WC) · Vendor claim
Files payroll taxes under PEO EIN; pooled large-group benefits access; PEO manages Workers’ Comp
Source page ↗ ·
Check record
Cigna required eligible employees · Vendor claim
Fully Insured / Plus: 51+ required eligible employees; Level Funding & ASO Plus: 25–999 required eligible employees; standard ASO: 200+ required eligible employees (footnote: 50+ / 25+ full-time employees in most states; excludes New Mexico).
Source page ↗ ·
Check record
Cigna health-plan funding · Vendor claim
ASO: employer funds claims directly + admin/stop-loss fees (100% real-time surplus); Level Funding: fixed monthly + 50%/67% renewal surplus
Source page ↗ ·
Check record
UnitedHealthcare funding guide · Vendor claim
Fully Insured (fixed premium, carrier risk) vs Level Funded (fixed + potential surplus share) vs Self-Funded ASO (employer pays claims + stop-loss)
Source page ↗ ·
Check record
Use the quote checklist →
Changing providers? Set the COBRA handoff duties in writing