Self-directed IRA custodian rules: what the custodian does, and what stays with you
A fee comparison only makes sense once you know what the fee buys. These rules come from the SEC, FINRA and state securities regulators, the IRS, the tax code, two Government Accountability Office audits, the Tax Court and a professional accounting journal. Each statement links to its source and read date.
1. What the custodian does, and what stays with you
Self-directed IRA custodians do not evaluate the quality or legitimacy of any investment or its promoters, and do not verify the financial information provided for an investment.
Custodians are only responsible for holding and administering the assets; most custodial agreements state the custodian has no responsibility for investment performance.
NASAA (December 2014) says a third-party custodian's sole obligation is to track and report contributions and distributions to the IRS to maintain the account's tax status, and that IRS approval does not mean an investment is safe.
NASAA describes the custodian as billing the investor for record keeping, and says it does not hold the investment funds or assets but transfers investment funds directly to the issuer.
In McNulty v. Commissioner (157 T.C. No. 10, 2021) the Tax Court said an IRA custodian is required to be responsible for the management and disposition of property held in a self-directed IRA, including custody, records and processing transactions, and that owners cannot have unfettered command over IRA assets without tax consequences.
GAO (2016) found owners investing through these accounts generally agree to oversee selection, management and monitoring of investments and to bear the consequences of most decisions, taking on a fiduciary-like role.
2. Check the custodian is legitimate
Regulators say to confirm a custodian is legitimate before depositing money; custodians may be banks, trust companies or IRS-approved entities, and the IRS nonbank list is one resource but not a complete list of every custodian.
The IRS maintains a list of entities approved under Treasury Regulation 1.408-2(e) to serve as nonbank trustees or custodians; the version linked on the read date is dated April 1, 2026, and the IRS says it updates the list frequently.
On November 14, 2026 none of the 14 custodian names in this project's scope (Equity Trust, The Entrust Group, Directed IRA, IRA Financial, IRA Club, IRAR Trust, STRATA Trust, Alto, Preferred Trust, Madison Trust, Advanta IRA, Horizon Trust, uDirect IRA, Rocket Dollar) appeared in the text of the IRS list dated April 1, 2026.
IRS Publication 590-A says the trustee or custodian must be a bank, a federally insured credit union, a savings and loan association, or an entity approved by the IRS to act as trustee or custodian.
Under 26 U.S.C. §408(n), 'bank' for IRA trustee purposes includes a corporation that, under the laws of its state of incorporation, is subject to supervision and examination by that state's banking commissioner or equivalent officer.
3. What an IRA cannot hold, and who must hold metals
The IRS says the law does not permit IRA funds to be invested in life insurance or collectibles, and an amount invested in collectibles is treated as distributed in that year, possibly with the 10% additional tax.
The IRS notes that IRA trustees may impose additional restrictions on investments and that many do not permit real estate because of administrative burden, even though the law allows it.
The IRS says the bullion exception to the collectibles rule applies only if the bullion is in the physical possession of a bank or an IRS-approved nonbank trustee, and that this also applies to an indirect purchase through an IRA-owned LLC.
Publication 590-B says permitted coins must be in the possession of the IRA custodian or trustee; if the owner or beneficiary takes possession, the coins are treated as distributed.
In McNulty v. Commissioner (157 T.C. No. 10, Nov. 18, 2021) the Tax Court treated gold coins bought through an IRA-owned LLC and kept in the owner's home as a taxable distribution, because the owner had complete, unfettered control over them regardless of the LLC's ownership and her role as its manager.
4. Prohibited transactions end the IRA
The IRS says that if an IRA owner or beneficiary engages in a prohibited transaction at any time in a year, the account stops being an IRA as of the first day of that year and is treated as distributing all its assets at fair market value on that day.
Publication 590-B says that if an IRA invests in nonpublicly traded assets or assets the owner directly controls, the risk of a prohibited transaction may be increased.
The IRS reporting-code page says IRAs holding non-marketable securities or closely held investments where the owner effectively controls the underlying assets have a greater potential for a prohibited transaction.
5. Tax the IRA itself may owe
Publication 590-B says an IRA with $1,000 or more of unrelated trade or business gross income must file Form 990-T, and that an IRA trustee is permitted to file it on the IRA's behalf.
The Form 990-T instructions list trustees of IRAs with $1,000 or more of unrelated trade or business gross income among required filers, treat each account as a separate trust needing its own EIN, and treat a custodian as a trustee.
GAO (2016) found IRA owners are not always aware they must monitor gross income from certain unconventional assets, such as active businesses or debt-financed property, for ongoing federal tax that must be paid from the IRA; failure can bring underpayment penalties.
The Journal of Accountancy (2013) frames every self-directed IRA investment as two questions: is it a prohibited transaction under Sec. 4975, and if not, does it create unrelated business taxable income or unrelated debt-financed income taxed inside the IRA.
The Journal of Accountancy describes two ways to invest: the custodian executes each investment and the IRA owns the asset, or the IRA puts substantially all its cash into an LLC it owns, with the account holder as LLC manager, so the LLC owns the asset; both are legally viable and each has legal and tax challenges.
The Journal of Accountancy says the IRA/LLC (checkbook) structure puts the actual investments outside the custodian's view, which itself creates legal and tax compliance problems.
The Journal of Accountancy author reports it is common for custodians to forward Schedules K-1 to the owner without mentioning possible UBTI consequences, while disclaiming tax advice.
The Journal of Accountancy cautions that custodian and LLC-facilitator statements can be biased toward their own fees: custodians earn ongoing fees from the SDIRA, and facilitators are cut out if a basic SDIRA is used alone.
6. Annual valuation is your job, and it has a cost
Since 2015 IRA custodians must complete Form 5498 boxes 15a and 15b for specified assets: non-traded stock, non-traded debt, LLC interests, real estate, partnership or trust interests, non-exchange options and other assets without a readily available fair market value; at most two codes, or code H for more than two.
Regulators warn that custodians often list an alternative asset at its original purchase price, purchase price plus promoter-reported returns, or a promoter-provided price, and advise independently verifying values.
GAO (2016) found owners of hard-to-value assets can struggle to give custodians updated fair market values for IRS annual reporting, and that late values can lead a custodian to distribute the assets prematurely at a stale value, risking the account's tax-favored status.
GAO recommended in 2016 that the IRS tell owners and custodians how to determine and document fair market value for hard-to-value assets; on the read date the GAO page showed that recommendation as still open, pending IRS regulations.
GAO (2020) reported the IRS identified about 2 million IRAs holding certain hard-to-value assets as of 2016, with about 20 percent of the forms missing fair market value amounts, and that enforcement for such IRAs needs labor-intensive audits.
7. How common these accounts are
GAO (2016): 17 of the 26 custodians it identified reported nearly half a million accounts holding unconventional assets at the end of 2015, mostly IRAs; the overall prevalence is unknown.
GAO (2020) stated only about 2 percent of IRAs are invested in unconventional assets and that IRS Publications 590-A and 590-B give limited information on barred investments, prohibited transactions, unrelated business income and fair market value.
8. What regulators say about fees and tax rules
Regulators warn that self-directed IRA fees may be significantly higher than other investment accounts, may include opening, annual, administrative, asset-specific and transaction fees, and vary among custodians.
Regulators say investing through a self-directed IRA requires following IRS rules that do not apply to other IRAs, and failures can bring extra taxes, penalties or loss of tax-deferred status.
This is why the fee detail page keeps each fee unit with its own condition instead of adding them into one annual total.
These are attributed public statements, not legal or tax advice for your account. Consult a tax adviser before investing through a self-directed IRA.