Contractor coverUS CONSTRUCTION · 11 SOURCED CARRIERS & BROKERS

CONTRACTOR INSURANCE

Compare contractor carriers & COI access

Trade appetite, coverages, price benchmarks, COI access, and AM Best disclosures across 11 sellers with sourced details. Missing terms stay visible.

CARRIER & BROKER COMPARISON

Key differences across 11 sourced sellers

Source URLs & read dates →

The Hartford

Carrier (Artisan BOP / GL referral)
Trades & appetiteNo direct GL on page; refers to Tivly · Artisan BOP for skilled tradesSeparate GL referral page vs Artisan BOP
Trades & conditions

Contractor GL page states no direct Hartford product is available and refers visitors to third-party partner Tivly.

Applies to the contractor General Liability page (hartford-gl-contractors); Artisan Contractor BOP is offered on a separate page.

Skilled trades: electrical, flooring, tiling, HVAC, drywall, plumbing, concrete and paving, fencing, glazing, masonry/bricklaying, pool/spa, and independent specialty contractors.

Applies to Artisan and Service Contractor policies (hartford-artisan-bop); excludes general-contractor GL routed to Tivly.

Coverage & limitsArtisan BOP (GL, property/tools, business income) + optional lines
Coverage details

Combines General Liability, Commercial Property (tools, equipment, jobsite supplies), and Business Income; optional Workers’ Comp, Professional Liability, Auto, Umbrella, and Cyber.

GL typically does not cover faulty workmanship; coverage depends on trade, policy terms, and state availability.

Quote & price basisAvg Artisan BOP ~$206/mo ($2,467/yr); portfolio estimatePortfolio avg only; not a quote
Quote & payment terms

Average ~$206/mo ($2,467/yr) for Artisan BOP; actual price quoted by trade, employees, location, claims history, coverages, and limits.

Disclosed portfolio estimate only, not an offer or guarantee of premium or coverage; actual price determined at quote.

COI accessRequest COI anytime via account
COI details

Customers can request a certificate of insurance through their Hartford account at any time.

Account eligibility, delivery time, fees, endorsement steps and policy conditions are not established here.

AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage · Quote/price · COI

ERGO NEXT

Digital carrier
Trades & appetiteSkilled trades & general contractors (solo or small crews)
Trades & conditions

Covers electrical, insulation, metal erection, roofing, plumbing, handyman, HVAC, carpentry, concrete, excavation, drywall, masonry, painting, solar, welding, and general contractors.

Availability and licensing requirements vary by state, city, and trade.

Coverage & limitsGL + optional E&O (workmanship), WC, Tools, Auto, BOP
Coverage details

Contractor General Liability plus optional Contractors’ E&O (workmanship errors), Workers’ Comp, Tool & Equipment, Commercial Auto, Commercial Property, and BOP.

GL does not apply if you or your employees suffer a work-related injury or illness (requires Workers’ Comp) or workmanship errors (Contractors’ E&O).

Quote & price basisOnline quote (~10 min); no fixed base rate
Quote & payment terms

100% online purchase in ~10 minutes; priced by trade, business size, employees, revenue, limits/deductible, location, years in business, and claims history.

No fixed base rate published on contractor GL page.

COI accessInstant digital COI at no added cost
COI details

Download or share an instant digital certificate of insurance via web or mobile app at no additional cost.

Eligible policies, exceptions, certificate changes and contract fit are not established here.

AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage · Quote/price · COI

Acuity

Regional / multi-state carrier
Trades & appetiteSolo to large firms across trade & heavy construction
Trades & conditions

Covers solo operations to large construction firms across steelwork, wallpapering, framing, road building, excavation, remodeling, home building, concrete, fencing/decking, roofing/windows/siding, and more.

Sold via independent agents across Acuity operating territory.

Coverage & limitsBis-Pak BOP, GL, WC, Auto, Builders’ Risk, Equipment, E&O
Coverage details

Includes Bis-Pak BOP, GL, Workers’ Comp, Commercial Auto, Builders’ Risk/Installation, Contractors’ Equipment, E&O, Additional Insured endorsements, and Voluntary Property Damage.

Includes free OSHA 10-hour training (locations across operating territory) and free 24/7 Acuity Nurse Helpline for Workers’ Compensation insureds.

Quote & price basisUnknown from reviewed evidence
COI access24/7 COI via independent agent or website
COI details

Get a certificate of insurance from your independent insurance agent or online through Acuity’s website 24/7.

Requires active Acuity policy; endorsement terms depend on policy.

AM Best ratingAM Best A+ (Superior), Stable (Mar 2025 article)Carrier article 2025-03-19; verify at AM Best
Rating details

AM Best A+ (Superior), Stable outlook (23rd consecutive year in Mar 19, 2025 article); S&P A+ reaffirmed in 2024.

Carrier-published announcement dated March 19, 2025; current rating requires independent verification at ambest.com.

Sources: Appetite · Coverage · COI · AM Best

Travelers

National carrier (Jan 2020 guide)
Trades & appetiteSpecialty trades; subcontracted work up to 25% of revenue (Jan 2020 guide) · Max size: $10M TIV, $750K payroll, 25 power units (Jan 2020)Jan 2020 Master Pac guide; current applicability unknown
Trades & conditions

Target specialty trade contractors (interior carpenters, flooring, electricians, HVAC, landscapers, painters, plumbers); 3+ yrs same ownership, subcontracted work up to 25% of revenue (must generally be eligible for Master Pac); excludes lead/asbestos, hospitals, industrial plants.

Source PDF is dated © 2020 / BSLBR.0001-D Rev. 1-20 (January 2020 revision); current underwriting applicability is unknown. Subcontracted work up to 25% of revenue requires general Master Pac eligibility; CA, CO, and state-specific appetite restrictions apply.

Select Accounts Master Pac maximum contractor account size (Jan 2020 guide): $10M TIV/account ($5M/location), $750,000 annual payroll, 25 power units.

Classified as underwriting eligibility/appetite (not policy coverage limits). Applies to Select Accounts small-business Master Pac program in the © 2020 / BSLBR.0001-D Rev. 1-20 guide; CA, CO, and state-specific restrictions apply; current applicability is unknown.

Coverage & limitsUnknown from reviewed evidence
Quote & price basisUnknown from reviewed evidence
COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingAM Best A++ (Jan 2020 guide; unconfirmed)Jan 2020 Master Pac guide; current applicability unknown
Rating details

AM Best rating of A++ stated for certain Travelers Insurance Companies pool subsidiaries in © 2020 / Rev. 1-20 guide; current 2026 rating unconfirmed.

Extracted from © 2020 / BSLBR.0001-D Rev. 1-20 PDF guide; does not establish current 2026 AM Best rating (verify specific subsidiary at ambest.com).

Sources: Appetite · Size cap · AM Best

Progressive

Commercial / partner carrier
Trades & appetiteGeneral & trade contractors (online ~8 min or agent)
Trades & conditions

Construction, carpenter, plumber, electrician, landscaper, painter, handyman, HVAC, tile/flooring, and general contractors.

Coverage provided and serviced by affiliated and third-party insurers; online quote in as little as eight minutes or via agent.

Coverage & limitsGL, Auto, BOP, WC, E&O, inland marine (GL excludes uninsured subs & own tools)Excludes uninsured subs & own tools on GL
Coverage details

GL (with product liability), Commercial Auto, BOP, Workers’ Comp, E&O (with vicarious liability), and inland marine endorsement for tools and equipment.

Page explicitly notes GL will not cover damage to your own tools, equipment, or property (requires inland marine) and will not cover damage or injury caused by subcontractors you hire if they do not have their own contractors insurance.

Quote & price basisUnknown from reviewed evidence
COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage

Liberty Mutual

Agent-sold carrier
Trades & appetiteSpecialty trades via independent agents
Trades & conditions

Carpenters, electricians, fence builders, painters, septic contractors, flooring installers, telecom installers, HVAC, and plumbers; sold via independent agents.

Page notes insurers generally do not sell a single standard "construction business insurance" package; customized via independent agents.

Coverage & limitsBOP, Property, GL, Cyber, Auto, WC, Umbrella, Inland Marine, Bonds
Coverage details

Offers BOP, Commercial Property, General Liability, Cyber, Commercial Auto, Workers’ Comp, Umbrella, Inland Marine, Farm, and Surety bonds.

Cost varies depending on coverage needed to address unique risks; no flat rate published.

Quote & price basisAuditable premium can use payroll, sales or total cost.Initial estimates can change after actual exposure is audited. Confirm the policy’s rating basis and rate.Source & date
COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage

Nationwide

National carrier
Trades & appetiteResidential & light commercial trades (HVAC excl. LPG)
Trades & conditions

Residential/light commercial electrical, HVAC (no LPG), plumbing, flooring, painting, remodeling, interior carpentry, landscaping, garage doors, fencing, seal coating, and concrete/paving.

Explicitly notes HVAC (no LPG); products, coverages, and discounts vary by state and exclusions apply.

Coverage & limitsGL, Property & Inland Marine (tools), Auto, WC, Umbrella, Bonds
Coverage details

General Liability, Equipment & Tools (inland marine in any location/transit), Business Auto, Workers’ Comp, Property, Umbrella, and Surety bonds.

Includes loss control tools and resources; policy contracts and state availability govern.

Quote & price basisUnknown from reviewed evidence
COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage

Markel

Specialty / artisan carrier
Trades & appetiteArtisan & building-service trades via appointed agents
Trades & conditions

Appliance repair, carpet cleaning, electrical, fencing, finish/trim carpentry, home furnishing install, HVAC, interior decorating/painting, landscaping, and lawn sprinklers.

Quoted through appointed Markel agents.

Coverage & limitsProperty (incl. A/R & business income), GL, WC, optional EPL
Coverage details

Property (building, equipment, accounts receivable, business income, computer interruption), General Liability, Workers’ Comp, and optional EPL endorsement.

Markel portals also distinguish admitted (mPortal) and non-admitted (Markel Online) lines.

Quote & price basisUnknown from reviewed evidence
COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Appetite · Coverage

Simply Business

18-carrier broker marketplace
Trades & appetiteUnknown from reviewed evidence
Coverage & limitsGL limits $1M–$2M (18-carrier marketplace)
Coverage details

General Liability coverage limits of $1M to $2M (varies by state and business); instant online proof of insurance.

Broker marketplace comparing 18 carriers; exact policy forms and limits depend on state and selected carrier.

Quote & price basisGL from $68.75/mo, WC from $38.91/mo (10th pct Jul–Dec 2025); Tools from $20.83/mo (lowest limit); down payment possibleGL/WC: 10th pct Jul–Dec 2025; Tools: lowest limit (period unknown); down payment possible
Quote & payment terms

18-carrier marketplace (<10 min): GL from $68.75/mo (10th pct, Jul–Dec 2025 sales; median $82/mo); WC from $38.91/mo (10th pct, Jul–Dec 2025 sales; median $132/mo); Tools & Equipment from $20.83/mo (lowest available limit, sample period unknown; median $37/mo). Final price and payment terms may include an initial down payment.

Page last updated 14 October 2026. Footnote * specifies GL and WC starting estimates are 10th-percentile monthly estimates from July–December 2025 sales and that final price and payment terms (which may include an initial down payment) vary by state, selected provider, and business details; footnote ‡ separately states Tools $20.83/mo reflects the lowest available limit (any Tools sample period is unstated/unknown).

COI accessUnknown from reviewed evidence
AM Best ratingUnknown from reviewed evidence
Sources: Limits · Quote/price

Hiscox

Carrier · contractor page
Trades & appetiteHiscox markets contractor cover to general contractors, finish carpenters, handymen and skilled trades.The page names General Liability and Professional Liability options. Coverage is subject to underwriting and may not be offered in every state; no exact trade acceptance or price is established.Source & date
Coverage & limitsGeneral Liability and Professional Liability options.Limits and exact trade/state eligibility require underwriting. The marketing page does not establish that a particular loss is covered.Source & date
Quote & price basisUnknown from the saved source
COI accessUnknown from the saved source
AM Best ratingUnknown from the saved source

Thimble

Broker platform · GL workflow
Trades & appetiteUnknown from the saved source
Coverage & limitsThimble says its General Liability policies include blanket designated additional-insured and waiver-of-subrogation endorsements.Broker-portal guidance says adding a certificate holder generates the endorsements behind the COI. The actual policy wording still controls.Source & date
Quote & price basisUnknown from the saved source
COI accessThimble brokers can view, download and share existing certificates from the active policy’s Documents section.These are broker-account instructions, not a measured issue time or a promise that every coverage change is instant.Source & date
AM Best ratingUnknown from the saved source

Shows 11 sellers with at least one sourced statement. New Hiscox contractor and Thimble certificate details sit alongside the earlier 9-seller comparison. Chubb, Unlimited Contractors Insurance, and CoverWallet remain unsourced. See method and retrieval status.

BEFORE YOU SEND PROOF

Three questions worth asking

Take the project’s exact insurance wording to your agent or carrier.

  1. Who can request and share a certificate on my account, and how fast?
  2. Does this contract require an additional-insured endorsement or waiver of subrogation?
  3. Which subcontractor, builder’s-risk, or faulty-workmanship exclusions apply to my trade?

MORE DETAIL

Check additional-insured fees, completed work and removal rules

Why a premium audit can change your final bill